Regular visitors to The Wild Reed would know that I have great admiration and respect for Dusty, for reasons which I talk about here. Today I remember and celebrate Dusty's life and music by sharing the rare solo version of the song "Wherever Would I Be?" This beautiful Diane Warren-penned ballad was originally released as a duet with Daryl Hall, and featured on what would be Dusty's last album, 1995's A Very Fine Love.
In the indispensable book, The Complete Dusty Springfield, author Paul Howes notes that:
"Wherever Would I Be?" wasn't initially intended to be a duet. Dusty recorded the song solo at the Nashville sessions and it was only later that the record company decided another voice should be added. . . . Without wanting to denigrate [Daryl Hall's] performance – the blond half of Hall & Oates has an impressive pair of lungs – Dusty's solo version is a much better record. Dusty worked on her vocals as a solo recording, line by line, probably syllable by syllable, and would doubtless have had a completely different approach to it had she known it was to have been a duet. . . . The solo version didn't make an appearance on A Very Fine Love but was a bonus track on a CD single. It was also used in preference to the duet on the 1998 Mercury CD Dusty, as well as [the four-CD box set] Simply Dusty two years later.
The video below which accompanies Dusty's solo version of "Wherever Would I Be" was created by TheMotownBoy, who artfully blends parts of the song's original music video with some wonderful archival footage of Dusty. This video is followed by an excerpt from Dave Godin's essay at the beginning of Sharon Davis' 2008 book A Girl Called Dusty: An Intimate Portrait of Dusty Springfield. Enjoy!
The trouble with "history" is that when you live through it, it is "now," and it is only after it has been distanced by time that you see it against a broader backdrop. I mention this because reflecting on Dusty Springfield today, I get all sorts of thoughts and perspectives which perhaps would not have occurred to me when she was at the height of her stardom. For not only was Dusty a vocalist and personality that people loved and admired, she was also a cultural icon . . . What I loved most about Dusty on the occasions I met her, was that there was nothing of the "star" about her. She radiated star quality for sure, but behind this she was charming, friendly and, amazingly for someone whom fame had touched, good mannered!. I wish that as she got older she had been given the opportunity to perhaps move into acting because I feel sure her huge emotional reserves could have been successfully channeled in that direction but, alas, it was not to be.
Like all great stars she had ambiguity; she sang and radiated warmth and affection, and yet, a tiny element of sadness and loneliness was also visible; a paradox that was perhaps more universally recognized on a subconscious level by her public than she or her record companies ever realized. When you become a star or a celebrity it is sometimes difficult to know just why this has happened, and it's easy to fret that one day you'll be "found out" and everyone will realize you are just another human being who happens to have a special and unusual talent. But it is a paradox which makes such people all the more loveable.
Dusty did not always have confidence in herself. She did not always cherish herself. And she was troubled by the gulf between what she had been told life was all about, and what life demonstrated to her it was really all about. . . Anybody can be a star if they are determined and ruthless enough, but to be a human being requires skill, talent and artistry. Dusty managed to be both, and being the one never compromised the other.
– Dave Godin
For more of Dusty at The Wild Reed, see:
Remembering Dusty – Eleven Years On
Dusty Springfield: Queer Icon
The Other "Born This Way"
The Sound of Two Decades Colliding . . .
Dusty Springfield: "Wasn't Born to Follow"
No Stranger Am I
Time and the River
Remembering a Great Soul Singer
A Song and Challenge for 2012
Classic Dusty II
Classic Dusty III
Classic Dusty IV
Classic Dusty V
Something In Your Eyes
Related Off-site Links:
Woman of Repute – My website dedicated to the life and music of Dusty Springfield.
Forever Dusty: "A New Musical About the Legendary Dusty Springfield"
Let's Talk Dusty
Dusty Springfield Tribute Site
The Definitive Dusty Springfield Collection